ABC is an isosceles triangle with AB = AC and D is a point on BC such that AD BC (Figure). To prove that
BAD =
CAD, a student proceeded as follows:
In ABD and
ACD,
AB = AC (Given)
B =
C (because AB = AC)
and ADB =
ADC
Therefore, ABD
ACD (AAS)
So, BAD =
CAD (CPCT)
What is the defect in the above arguments?
In ABC, AB = AC (Given)
ACB =
ABC (angles opposite to equal side are equal)
In ABD and
ACD
ABD =
ACD (given)
ABD =
ACD (from above)
ADB =
ADC (each 90°)
ABD
ACD
BAD =
CAD
So, the defect in the above-given argument, first prove
ABD =
ACD